Badmovies.org Forum

Other Topics => Entertainment => Topic started by: Kooshmeister on March 13, 2007, 08:33:53 PM



Title: Disney gun censorship?
Post by: Kooshmeister on March 13, 2007, 08:33:53 PM
I recently bought the Darkwing Duck Volume 1 DVD set. Great little cartoon compared to most stuff today, despite my ragging on it in my review of the pilot (which I ought to post on here sometime).

But I noticed something a little odd about one of the menus on one of the discs. Disc 3 to be precise, which features Taurus Bulba and his henchman Hammerhead (despite the fact the episodes they appear in are actually on Disc 1). The menus use pictures of the characters taken directly from frames of film in the episodes, so, let's look at the frame in question:

(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v609/Kooshmeister/dwd_censor2.jpg)
They're looking for Darkwing, who has disappeared, and Hammerhead has his revolver out.

But then we go over to the menu on Disc 3...

(http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v609/Kooshmeister/dwd_censor.jpg)
Same frame, same pose and everything, and Hammerhead's revolver is nowhere to be found!

Anyone else think this is really weird? I'm aware of this sort of thing happening, but when I noticed it, I just got so flabbergasted I had to share it.


Title: Re: Disney gun censorship?
Post by: Andrew on March 13, 2007, 09:35:31 PM
Hard to tell why they did that.  It could easily (and most likely) be the firearm issue.

As I understand it, the new version of "E.T." has the police all holding cell phones and such instead of guns.  I refuse to see that thing.  Actually, it seems that I refuse to watch "E.T." at all. 


Title: Re: Disney gun censorship?
Post by: Dennis on March 14, 2007, 12:42:22 AM
Guns are one of those topics that always seem to provoke the liberal extremists into foaming at the mouth fits of rage, at least here in La La Land. It is popular to believe that if your kids play with toy guns or indulge in any sort of rough or competitive play they are either going to be scarred for life or become serial killers. This is just B.S. I believe that most, if not all of the boys (and some of the girls too) of my generation, and the ones preceding it, and the ones that followed it have played army, cowboys and Indians, cops and robbers, whatever you want to call it, it involved role playing and toy guns. Some of us actually own real firearms as adults, I do, and I have not felt the need to kill anyone, or commit some sort of violent crime. I do feel a bit more secure in my home knowing that I have tools that I can use to protect my home and family if the need ever arises. I am not a "gun nut", but I believe that if our government ever tries to take away the right to keep and bear arms then this country will be in trouble. It would not surprise me to find out that the Disney Company edited out the revolver, must be politically correct, and although I may have missed it, I don't see them re-releasing Davy Crockett, as I recall didn't he use a rifle in this Disney film, and doesn't the film show him actually shooting people. I doubt that they'll be letting this one out any time soon.
Sorry I took so long but this kind of thing really gets me going. :hot:


Title: Re: Disney gun censorship?
Post by: Zapranoth on March 14, 2007, 01:19:04 AM
Hard to tell why they did that.  It could easily (and most likely) be the firearm issue.

As I understand it, the new version of "E.T." has the police all holding cell phones and such instead of guns.  I refuse to see that thing.  Actually, it seems that I refuse to watch "E.T." at all. 

Holy crap!   Did Andrew just say there's something he won't watch?

Andrew, who has watched "Pigs," who has watched "Heartbeeps," won't watch ET?

*double takes*

Katie, is it true?  He won't watch ET?


Title: Re: Disney gun censorship?
Post by: Ash on March 14, 2007, 01:49:44 AM
It is popular to believe that if your kids play with toy guns or indulge in any sort of rough or competitive play they are either going to be scarred for life or become serial killers. This is just B.S. I believe that most, if not all of the boys (and some of the girls too) of my generation, and the ones preceding it, and the ones that followed it have played army, cowboys and Indians, cops and robbers, whatever you want to call it, it involved role playing and toy guns.

When I was 10-12 years of age, I had a pretty decent sized collection of toy pistols, rifles & machine guns.  I'd say that I had at least 20.
My favorite one was a very realistic looking plastic AK-47 that made the rat-a-tat noise when you pulled the trigger. 
(until I tripped over a rock while running with it and snapped the barrell off   :bluesad:)
And this was before federal regulations required the tips of the guns to be orange or red.

I had all those toy guns and just look at how I turned out!   :teddyr:


Title: Re: Disney gun censorship?
Post by: quabrot on March 14, 2007, 02:24:21 AM
Wow... I'm behind.... I didn't know Darkwing Duck was on DVD yet!


Title: Re: Disney gun censorship?
Post by: Poogie on March 14, 2007, 11:53:49 AM
When I was younger there were guns in our house. My father was a policeman and he had to have guns. We were taught that the gun, when shot could kill someone or yourself. It's not like what you see on TV, where someone gets shot and jumps up and runs away like they got hit by a rock, or as seen on cartoons where someone got shot and 2 seconds later you see them with 2 band-aides in the shape of a X on their wound. If we were interested in seeing or holding the gun he would be sitting right next to us, we were never allowed to touch it unless he handed it to us. The guns were never loaded, I should say the ones we saw were never loaded. He kept one under his side of the bed at night that was loaded only when he went to bed. When we were young everyone watched TV together as a family and we were taught that certain things on TV are not real. If parents would talk and explain things to there kids honestly we wouldn't have some of the problems we have today. A lot of parents turn on the TV, as a babysitter, and leave the kids to make up their own minds about things and this doesn't work with all kids.
OOPS! I think this turned into a rant...sorry about that. I'll probably have to pay the consequences.....  :teddyr:


Title: Re: Disney gun censorship?
Post by: Yaddo 42 on March 14, 2007, 09:56:53 PM
I usually want to read into anti-gun revisionism, but on that menu removing the gun seems mostly harmless, it's a cut and paste of characters from the show. Plus if the gun were used in that menu it would appear to be pointing at Darkwing Duck who looks startled already. Older kids and viewers can suss this out as harmless, but maybe the worry warts at the House o' Mouse thought it would spook the little ones.   

My dad hunted most of his life, he was the one who taught his siblings and later the rest of us to shoot and how to handle firarms. I have a memory of him taking me shooting at the age of 5. Basically him doing the work, guess he was building up the muscle memory and getting me used to firing .22s and .410 and 20 gauge shotguns.

Before we ever got near the guns at target practice or at turkey shoots we got the Speech. How dangerous guns are, how you treat every gun like it's loaded so you don't act stupid when they are and because sooner or later you will be wrong and one will be loaded when you are sure it isn't. How you never point a gun at anything you aren't will to kill or destroy because it can't come back ever, this is real life not the movies or cartoons. We did not shoot at water. We didn't shoot at anything we didn't know what was behind it, because bullets travel far and fast. The guns in the house were his guns and we were not to go near them unless he allowed us near them, and we only got to use them at his discretion. We didn't do anything stupid with his guns or anyone else's, because he would find out about it. Even if nothing bad happened we would never get near a gun again unless he let us and we couldn't count on that time ever turning up.


Title: Re: Disney gun censorship?
Post by: raj on March 15, 2007, 02:42:01 PM
My sister & her husband are some of those anti-gun nuts (otherwise nice people).  They've never let my nephew have any toy guns.  So of course he pretends other toys are guns.  Mwahahahahaha.


Title: Re: Disney gun censorship?
Post by: Andrew on March 15, 2007, 03:54:19 PM
I grew up with firearms, including my own pellet rifles and .22 rifle.  Also, my father's rifle was always behind the front door and my grandfather's shotgun was likewise easily where I could get it.  Dad gave me much the same rundown on firearms as Yaddo's.  Never, in all my time as a youth, did I ever think about using a firearm against another person.  It was only after I was older, and began to encounter events which might involve someone else threatening serious bodily harm against someone, did I consider using a shotgun against someone.

As has been said, a firearm is a tool.  Always treat it as loaded.  Never aim at something you do not intend to shoot.  Keep the weapon on safe until you intend to fire.  Keep your finger off the trigger until you intend to fire.  Know your right and left lateral limits and pay attention to what is behind your target.  Never fire at something that could cause a ricochet.  The best targets are backed with a bullet trap or dirt backstop.

Really, the big thing with firearms is common sense.  When you think about everything typed above (and other factors in safely using a firearm) they jump out at you as common sense.


Title: Re: Disney gun censorship?
Post by: Raffine on March 15, 2007, 05:24:47 PM
Well, P.C.  Disney did edit out Pecos Bill's cigarette in the rerelease of Melody Time, so them rubbing out a pistol is perfectly believable.

(http://i46.photobucket.com/albums/f112/drsd2kill/newebay/MELODYTIME_UNCUT_1.jpg)
Smoke 'em if you got 'em.

(http://i46.photobucket.com/albums/f112/drsd2kill/newebay/MELODYTIME_CUT_1.jpg)
...or not.


Title: Re: Disney gun censorship?
Post by: Viktorcrayon on March 15, 2007, 05:26:19 PM
I think it might be an aesthetic choice, rather than cencorship, but thats just me.

Also, i must admit (and this will not be popular on this board, i fear) that i can't understand american gun policy.

Everyone has one to feel safer, but the policy also makes it easier for people who shouldnt have it to get acces to it. I guess i would have one as well, if i lived in a country where they are so readily available!


Title: Re: Disney gun censorship?
Post by: Yaddo 42 on March 15, 2007, 06:00:28 PM
Yeah, Raffine, the removal of cigarettes, and not just by Disney, is stupid also. Because as we know no one smoked in the Old West. I remember a minor hoopla when a box set of Simon & Garfunkel was released and a photo of Paul Simon was digitally altered to remove a cigarette. He was gesturing with it in his hand, so with the smoke gone, his finger position looked odd. It actually drew attention to what was missing.

I hate smoking, but if it was in a film, TV show, or picture leave it in. It's like seeing old talk show clips, say Johnny Carson on The Tonight Show or Mike Wallace on his old interview shows, they were smoking all the time.

Viktorcrayon, not everyone owns firearms, and not everyone one owns them for protection. The Second Amendment in the Bill of Rights of our Constitution addresses gun ownership by private citizens. Even its meaning and the reasons that Amendment is included are debated today. Besides federal regulations, guns laws vary widely by state, and even by city.


Title: Re: Disney gun censorship?
Post by: Ed, Ego and Superego on March 15, 2007, 06:05:50 PM
The dichotomy is that there are many many responsible, smart and safe gun owners (like our friends on here).   These folks take the classes, teach the children, wear safety gear, and register guns as needed.   They are the ones who are hurt by draconian laws.  There are also many many dumbasses and criminal types who would not obey the laws anyway. .   I'm an anti-gun gun owner, if that makes sense.  I own guns, love to shoot, and was a compeitive shooter for a while.  But I know there are folks who should not even be allowed pointy objects, let alone guns.    We need to figure out how to weed out the responsible from the irresponsible.
I'm not saying we shouldn't have laws, but we need a diferent approach to crimes (and what oughtta be crimes) commited with guns.  I once read that we should prosecute any crime involving a gun to a higher degree, maybe thats the fix.  BBut what do I know?
-Ed





Title: Re: Disney gun censorship?
Post by: Viktorcrayon on March 15, 2007, 06:31:12 PM
Viktorcrayon, not everyone owns firearms, and not everyone one owns them for protection. The Second Amendment in the Bill of Rights of our Constitution addresses gun ownership by private citizens. Even its meaning and the reasons that Amendment is included are debated today. Besides federal regulations, guns laws vary widely by state, and even by city.

I'm aware of this  :smile:

Still, i just can't help but think that it's unhealthy to have such liberal gun laws. But hey, i'm from a different culture. I don't really have any right to comment it, as i simply don't know enough about the subject.

Also, this is a chance for me to say, that i LOVE the ignatz avatar. That comic was simply 50 years ahead of its time.


Title: Re: Disney gun censorship?
Post by: Yaddo 42 on March 15, 2007, 06:45:33 PM
I know there have been programs like Project Exile for gang related/gun crimes that have been fairly successful.

And I have known my share of irresponsible gun owners, I've mentioned the people showing off their "toys" who hand or try to hand me loaded guns before. And people with their stories of injuries and close calls while clean guns they "thought" were unloaded. My best friend bought a rifle he had to keep at my house since he couldn't trust his father to keep his hands off of it when he was away.

My dad was an NRA member for years, then let his membership run out later in life because he opposed their lobbying efforts to prevent restriction of semi-auto assault rifles and things like TEC-9s in the 80s. He didn't like the idea of weapons with high-capacity magazines and fairly rapid fire in the hands of lots of people. But he also felt using a scope in most cases was lazy shooting.

Of course you can comment, I know I like hearing from the perspective of someone who didn't grow up in an environment different from the one I know. Thanks about the avatar, wish I had discovered the strip sooner, only knew it by reputation for a while. It really is a classic.


Title: Re: Disney gun censorship?
Post by: BeyondTheGrave on March 16, 2007, 10:09:33 PM
I'm anti-gun to a certain degree. I own lots of Jane and military guns books. I understand guns for hunting (which I don't like) and hand guns for house protection but Assualt rifles and sub-machine guns with high magazine and stop power we don't need.

Maybe because I grew up and still live in NYC where guns are a problem. People go to other states buy guns with no problem and sell them here.