Ranking Soulsbourne 2022

[ER]

1. Dark Souls
2. Dark Souls 2
3. Demon's Souls
4. Dark Souls 3
5. Elden Ring
6. Bloodborne

[WingedSerpent]

I've played a bit of Demon Souls and that's really it. 

[ER]

If re-playability is a strong argument for titles being good, then every one of these must be masterpieces, considering they still get me to play them, in one case even after over eleven years and countless hours. I guess I respect the fact there never was/hasn't yet been a sequel to Bloodborne, but I wish there had been.

[Jim H]

If re-playability is a strong argument for titles being good, then every one of these must be masterpieces, considering they still get me to play them, in one case even after over eleven years and countless hours. I guess I respect the fact there never was/hasn't yet been a sequel to Bloodborne, but I wish there had been.

Yeah, I've beaten Dark Souls at least a dozen times, and immediately replayed 2 and 3 several times, which is extremely rare for me in longer games.  

My ranking:

1. Dark Souls
2. Elden Ring
3. Dark Souls 2
4. Dark Souls 3
5. Bloodborne

N.A. - Demons's Souls (I have the PS5 remake, haven't played it yet)

I know I'm a weird one with Bloodborne, something just doesn't click for me with it.  I don't like the way the setting looks, it's just overflowing with clutter in a way that bugs me.  I found several parts of it kind of annoying or silly.  I also got lost in it, the only Souls game where that happened to me.  Never finished it.  I am going to give it another shot at some point though.