My perfect lineup:
V
Erik, The Phantom of the Opera
Raoul De Chagny
Dwarf Assistant
Eric Draven
Top-Dollar
Grange
Mica
T-Bird
Mothman
The Jersey devil
Spring-heel Jack
Dosu Kinuta
Oboro
Gozu
Meizu
The Tall Man
Reggie
Mike
Tim
Rocky
Yomiko Readman
Michelle Chang
Maggie Mui
Anita King
Drake Anderson
Mac
Bloo
Wilt
Eduardo
Coco
Corky and Fats
Willard Stiles
Paula Peterson
Slasher
Samurai
Lt. Devin
Doc
Danny Ocean
Sam Harmon
Josh Howard
Jimmy Foster
Tony Bergdoff
hellboy
Liz Sherman
Abe Sapien
Johann Strauss
Roger the Humonculous
Bandit 1 and 2 out of Dance of the Dwarfs
El Gringo Loco
Jigsaw
Amanda
Mary Shaw
David Lincoln
Hans
Junior
Abraham Van Helsing
Aurora Ash
Humvee
Orlock
187
Dark Helmet
President Skroob
Colonel Sandurz
Commaderette Zircon
Pizza the Hutt
Bret
Jermaine
Murray
Roy
Guy
Peace
Dr. Engelem
Commander Jim
Jin
Aaron
Jasmine
Darth Marlon Brando
Donald Pleasence Prime
Yossarian
Dunbar
Nately
Major Major Major Major
Hungry Joe
Also Mario would be cool, and Luigi as an extra treat