I did get spooked a couple of times and a few of the puzzles were interesting but when I drop 30+ bucks for a game I get a little irritated when I can finish it in an afternoon and it has almost no reply value.
Well there is replay value. Depending on different things you do, the game will change. Of course, since you beat it, the official UFO ending is now opened up. Find 13 UFOs and get the goofy ending at the end. I'll be trying for that later.
Silent Hill 1 is suppose to be good and I will try to play it at some point, but right now, I need to play something a bit more cheery to combat that depressing and freaky game. Back to Paper Mario!