GoHawks
Bad Movie Lover
Karma: 22
Posts: 147
Happiness is a dancing beagle.
|
|
« Reply #1 on: March 29, 2014, 08:01:57 PM » |
|
I have no clue what this film might be; I just want to talk about the actual post.
This post is a perfect example of how I wish everyone, especially new members, would ask about movies they are looking for. It has just about everything one could ask for. Please indulge me as I go through it.
The subject line is meaningful and specific. Too many queries are titled something like "What is this movie?" or "Help with this film!". Before even reading the post, I already know something about this movie. It helps to get the brain thinking along the right lines as you read more about the film in the body of the post.
The user mentions where and when (s?)he saw the film, with specifics. I mean, obviously if you are asking about a film you have seen, then you have seen it. But where? In the theater? On HBO or some other premium cable channel? On regular broadcast TV? And when? Just saying something like "really old" doesn't really tell us much, without knowing what that means to the person who wrote it. I have seen this phrase used to describe movies anywhere from the 1930s to five years ago, when the questioner was still in grade school!
The plot is described as well as can be remembered, in (I assume) chronological order, and with doubtful portions pointed out. I can remember several movie descriptions on this board where the poster jumped all over the timeline of the movie without even mentioning that they were doing so. I realize that not everyone remembers every detail of every movie; that is partly why this board is here. It does help the rest of us tremendously, though, if unnecessary complications (e.g. knowingly describing the movie out of order) were not introduced.
Mention is made of the actors and what other films they may or may not have been in. Once again, if you're asking about a film, you probably don't have a clue who was in it. But if you do, mentioning that fact, or telling us that you don't know, helps us better figure it out for you.
Although this post does not do this, another nice thing to include (related to the last paragraph) is a list of films that you have already verified are not the film you are looking for. I wouldn't ding this poster for not including any, as this description doesn't sound like it could fit more than one film anyway.
This post is broken up into manageable paragraphs. This is a huge benefit. Not everyone is Shakespeare, but if you expect someone else to read your writing, make it readable. If I saw a post this long with no paragraph breaks, I wouldn't even bother reading it. (I have seen a post this long on this board not only with no paragraph breaks, but the entire post was one long sentence!)
Lastly, and this one is mostly personal and probably doesn't belong with the rest, but the poster thanks us (presumably) for reading the post and giving some thought to what the movie might be. Politeness always helps, in my book. (Also, and I hesitate to mention this, but I hate it when someone says "Thanks in advance!". No. Thank me for doing something, or thank me for agreeing to do something, but don't thank me for something I haven't yet done.)
I realize that not every film search is amenable to all of the above suggestions. Further, I do not claim that I always include all of the aforementioned information; on the contrary, I fully admit that I have been guilty of shall we say less than informative posts. I am merely saying that I wish that all queries would be as informative as this post is. I will now get off my soapbox and fade back into obscurity. Thank you.
|