Quote from: Dr. Whom on December 31, 2025, 11:31:33 AMWake Up Dead Man. A Knives Out Mysteru (2025)
there is no antagonist. In an ordinary murder mystery, there is always the threat that the killer will strike back and/or murder again to prevent getting caught. Here the protagonists are never in any jeopardy or under pressure.
People seem to like it, though.
would always instantly be able to identify the culprit. Among her other uhhh quirks, Rand saw murder as a pragmatic, even constructive act, thus only the strongest and most admirable protagonist could commit such an act in one of her stories.
After the first socially tinged KNIVES OUT and the more broadly satirical GLASS ONION, it's clear that Rian Johnson is, like Rand, an author of extreme principles, if probably oppositional to Rand in most ways. In the KNIVES OUT universe, the culprits are always "antagonists"... corrupt, callous, and/or outright evil characters whose general motivation is to make life less pleasant for the rest of the world. In order to complicate the mystery, Johnson fills his casts with such objectionable figures. In counterpoint, it's difficult to ever seriously suspect the second lead in these films of being the murderer - though WUDM does tease occasionally the idea, for funsies - because if one of Johnson's principled protagonists had committed a murder, they would do exactly what O'Connor's does in this film when he thinks he's somehow guilty........ they'd promptly turn themselves in. In the world of Benoit Blanc, it isn't just the crime that makes a character the Antagonist - it's the cover-up and the motivation. [END LIGHT NON-CLIMACTIC SPOILERS]



Quote from: Rev. Powell on December 31, 2025, 11:53:30 AM