Main Menu

Mike vs. Joel

Started by Olivia Bauer, May 26, 2016, 08:41:44 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Which MST3K Protagonist is Better?

Mike Nelson
Joel Hodgson
No preference

Olivia Bauer

Sorry I've been gone for so long. I'll try to post way more often. So I'm going to start with what is apparently a controversial question.

Mike Vs. Joel

I'm relatively new to MST3K so I can't really say who's better yet.

ulthar

Why does one have to be "better?"

It's not even a "No Preference" kind of thing.  I honestly don't get the cultural obsession with "better" and "best," especially stuff like this.

So, without an option that says "Who gives a Sh1t about stuff like this," I'll abstain completely.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Professor Hathaway:  I noticed you stopped stuttering.
Bodie:      I've been giving myself shock treatments.
Professor Hathaway: Up the voltage.

--Real Genius

lester1/2jr

They're both great but Mike is a little bit funnier. Many classic moments are with Joel though and I CERTAINLY prefer dr forester and tv's frank to pearl by a mile.

early Mike era pre Pearl >

indianasmith

Never watched the show . . . not one episode.  (ducks thrown bricks  :bouncegiggle:)
"I shall smite you in the nostrils with a rod of iron, and wax your spleen with Efferdent!!"

Rev. Powell

No preference. I started watching when Joel was host so I have a soft spot for him, but really, it's quite amazing that Mike was able to step in and do as well as he did with a character that was similar enough to keep the proper "affectionately sarcastic" tone while still having his own personality.

And of course, many of Joel's riffs were written by Mike (but not vice-versa).
I'll take you places the hand of man has not yet set foot...

SynapticBoomstick

Joel's dry delivery and Mike's dopey demeanor manage to share the same spot of fondness in my memories.
Kleel's rule is harsh :-B

Rev. Powell

Just speculation, but a year or two from now I don't think Jonah will be doing very well in polls against these two. He's got too much to live up to.
I'll take you places the hand of man has not yet set foot...

Flangepart

Quote from: indianasmith on May 26, 2016, 11:23:42 AM
Never watched the show . . . not one episode.  (ducks thrown bricks  :bouncegiggle:)
"Keep chuckin' 'em guys, he's a big target!"
"Aggressivlly eccentric, and proud of it!"

Chainsawmidget

I kinda liked Joel better, but it's a tough call. 

By far the best "Mads" were Dr. Forrester and TV's Frank though. 

Flangepart

It's simple really. Joel is their dad, and Mike is a frat brother. Me like both.
"Aggressivlly eccentric, and proud of it!"

WingedSerpent

Quote from: indianasmith on May 26, 2016, 11:23:42 AM
Never watched the show . . . not one episode.  (ducks thrown bricks  :bouncegiggle:)

How are those ducks managing to throw bricks?  They don't have hands.

Personally, I've always preferred Mike.  By the time MST3K was on a non- subscription tv channel, he was the host.  So I became a fan when he was the one making the riffs.
At least, that's what Gary Busey told me...

HappyGilmore

I voted no preference.

I like both. I've a soft spot for Joel, first one I saw and grew up with, created it, etc. My favorite films featured were Joel.

Mike brought something different to it. He was like their brother, so the relationship changed. And he's incredibly funny.
"The path to Heaven runs through miles of clouded Hell."

Don't get too close, it's dark inside.
It's where my demons hide, it's where my demons hide.