Fame or Shame: The Pro Wrestling Game

[Joe the Destroyer]

Hulk Hogan- 54
Undertaker- 54 SAVE
Sandman- 26
Ricky Steamboat- 16 KILL
Abdullah the Butcher- 30

[JaseSF]

Hulk Hogan- 56 SAVE
Undertaker- 54
Sandman- 26
Ricky Steamboat- 16
Abdullah the Butcher- 28 KILL

Hmm all of these guys all belong in the Hall of Fame, hence I'm kind of over the place how I vote. Sandman did indeed have some great ECW feuds and matches.

[HappyGilmore]

Hulk Hogan- 56
Undertaker- 54
Sandman- 28 (SAVE)
Steamboat- 16
Abdullah- 26 (KILL)

I'm a diehard ECW fan.

I'm not knocking Abdullah, but I'm relatively young (26) and I'd say he's had his biggest successes before I was born.  I only really got to see him in his brief run in ECW in '93 when I was 9.  I'm sure there's videos out there, I just don't know where besides YouTube.

[Mr. DS]

Hulk Hogan- 58 save
Undertaker- 54
Sandman- 26 kill
Steamboat- 16
Abdullah- 26

[JaseSF]

Hulk Hogan- 60 Save - HALL OF FAME
Undertaker- 54
Sandman- 24 KILL
Steamboat- 16
Abdullah- 26

I now nominate Hillbilly Jim.

New list:

Hillbilly Jim - 30
Undertaker - 54
Sandman - 24
Ricky Steamboat - 16
Abdullah the Butcher - 26

[Mr. DS]

I now nominate Hillbilly Jim.

I like your nomination.  Quite frankly it took me by surprise because I would have never thought of him so early.    Hillbilly Jim was a wonderfully fun gimmick that ran it's course nicely.  Though it got a bit silly once the other redneck relatives made their way into WWF.  Not sure how I'll vote on him but we'll see how the game goes.  This match is proof why one shouldn't mess with a country boy.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Ul8TtCUQts

[Joe the Destroyer]

Hillbilly Jim - 30 (good choice, btw)
Undertaker - 56 SAVE
Sandman - 24
Ricky Steamboat - 14 KILL
Abdullah the Butcher - 26

[Mr. DS]

Hillbilly Jim - 30
Undertaker - 58 SAVE
Sandman - 22 KILL
Ricky Steamboat - 14
Abdullah the Butcher - 26

[JaseSF]

Hillbilly Jim - 30
Undertaker - 60 SAVE HALL OF FAME
Sandman - 20 KILL
Ricky Steamboat - 14
Abdullah the Butcher - 26

I now nominate the original Gorgeous George from the 1950s and 1960s.

New list

Hillbilly Jim - 30
Gorgeous George - 30
Sandman - 20
Ricky Steamboat - 14
Abdullah the Butcher - 26

[Joe the Destroyer]

Hillbilly Jim - 30
Gorgeous George - 30
Sandman - 20
Ricky Steamboat - 12 KILL
Abdullah the Butcher - 28 SAVE

[Mr. DS]

Hillbilly Jim - 30
Gorgeous George - 32 save
Sandman - 18 kill
Ricky Steamboat - 12
Abdullah the Butcher - 28

[JaseSF]

Hillbilly Jim - 30
Gorgeous George - 32
Sandman - 16 kill
Ricky Steamboat - 14 SAVE
Abdullah the Butcher - 28

I've got to throw another save out to Ricky Steamboat. He's been in way too many good matches and feuds to not show some appreciation for all his work. He is without a doubt one of the best babyfaces, if not the best, of all-time constantly getting attacked by different heels and injured and then coming back and getting his Dragon's revenge. He's kind of like the wrestling version of Bruce Lee in some ways. 

[Joe the Destroyer]

Steamboat is a good wrestler.  I was torn between killing him and Sandman.  I like everyone on the list, really, but the difficulty is what makes it enjoyable.

[Joe the Destroyer]

Hillbilly Jim - 30
Gorgeous George - 32
Sandman - 14 KILL
Ricky Steamboat - 14
Abdullah the Butcher - 30 SAVE

[Mr. DS]

Hillbilly Jim - 32 SAVE (I may end up killing him sadly depending on the game)
Gorgeous George - 32
Sandman - 12 KILL
Ricky Steamboat - 14
Abdullah the Butcher - 30