1000 recordings to hear before you die - how many can you guess?

[HappyGilmore]

Exile in Guyville- Liz Phair

[zombie no.one]

^^ I was going to suggest this one. good shout

Instead I'll go for Love - 'Forever Changes'. I don't really like it that much, but I'm thinking objectively, in terms of albums that usually crop up on these type of lists...

[Mr. DS]

U2 Joshua Tree

[Rev. Powell]

Happy: you're right, Joe's Garage was already picked.  But +1 for "Exile in Guyville."
Derf: -1 for "Sugar." 
AHD: +1 for "A Love Supreme"
Jack: +1 for "Paranoid"
Newt: +1 for "Sweet Baby James."  +1 for "Tapestry." +1 for "Jesus Christ Superstar." = +3!
DCA: +1 for "Forever Changes"
DarkSider: +1 for "Joshua Tree"

That was one heck of a round for you guys.    It gets harder now since most of the obvious choices are gone.

Allhallowsday +5, Circus_Circus +4,  Newt +4, DCA +4,  Jack +2,  Pilgermann +1, Doggett + 0.5,  The DarkSider 0, Jim H. 0, Happy Gilmore 0, BTM -1, The Burgomaster -1, WilliamWeird -1, Andrew -3, Derf -4

[Psycho Circus]

Cream -Fresh Cream?

[Newt]

WOOT! 

Procol Harum: A Whiter Shade of Pale

[HappyGilmore]

The B-52's by The B-52's.  Their debut album from the late '70s/early '80s.  Best one, too.

[Psycho Circus]

Temptations - Ain't Too Proud To Beg ('cause it's my dad's favourite and he knows good motown)

[Rev. Powell]

Circus: you prove you are mortal.  -1 for "Fresh Cream."  But, I am giving you +2 for "Ain't Too Proud To Beg" because it's one of the very few singles he picked as "must hears".  Net: +1
Newt:  You got another single, "A Whiter Shade of Pale", that counts for +2. 
Happy: Sorry, no "B-52's." -1.

Newt +6, Allhallowsday +5, Circus_Circus +5, DCA +4,  Jack +2,  Pilgermann +1, Doggett + 0.5,  The DarkSider 0, Jim H. 0, Happy Gilmore -1, BTM -1, The Burgomaster -1, WilliamWeird -1, Andrew -3, Derf -4

[Psycho Circus]

Darn it! But thanks. 

Right....Abraxas by Santana? (sweats nervously...)

[Allhallowsday]

SERGE GAINSBOURG Histoire de Melody Nelson

[Rev. Powell]

Circus: +1 for "Abraxas"
AHD: +1 for "Histoire de Melody Nelson"

Newt +6, Allhallowsday +6, Circus_Circus +6, DCA +4,  Jack +2,  Pilgermann +1, Doggett + 0.5,  The DarkSider 0, Jim H. 0, Happy Gilmore -1, BTM -1, The Burgomaster -1, WilliamWeird -1, Andrew -3, Derf -4

[Allhallowsday]

BOB MARLEY Catch A Fire?  Nah, Burnin'   Burnin' is better but Catch A Fire started it all.  Both?

[HappyGilmore]

Paranoid by Black Sabbath?

[Rev. Powell]

BOB MARLEY Catch A Fire?  Nah, Burnin'   Burnin' is better but Catch A Fire started it all.  Both?

Get back to me when you make up your mind.   

Happy: "Paranoid" made it but it was already guessed by Jack.